LETTER TO THE EDITOR: Why a 5-Member Board of Selectmen Works

Sudbury resident Dan De Pompei points to facts about how an increase makes for better town governance.

I currently own property in two Massachusetts communities. Both communities have a Board of Selectmen-Town Manager form of governance. One community has three unpaid selectmen (the 3 Town) and the other has five unpaid selectmen (the 5 Town). 

The 3 Town has been struggling for several years to understand, fund and justify a waste water system. The 5 Town had a shovel ready program and received federal stimulus funds two years ago to finance its’ new waste water system. 

The 3 Town has been struggling for decades to understand what type of bicycle trail would be best for the Town. The 5 Town has miles of bicycle trails for the enjoyment of residents and visitors alike. 

The 3 Town limits citizen participation at Board of Selectmen (BOS) meetings to agenda items that have been submitted and approved by the BOS prior to the meeting. The 5 Town works to an agenda but welcomes citizen participation at BOS meetings and specifically schedules time for citizens’ comments. 

The 3 Town has a BOS majority of high tenure members who do not need to discuss or debate many topics because they have discussed and debated most topics before. The 5 Town has more frequent turnover within the BOS and is frequently challenged with new ideas from new members; all topics before the board are debated to the benefit of the new members and the benefit of new citizens.

The 3 Town has high assessed property values. The 5 Town has higher assessed property values and the 5 Town has a higher rate of appreciation in housing values. 

The 3 Town has one of the highest property tax burdens in the state. The 5 Town has one of the lowest property tax burdens in the state.

The 3 Town has a AAA bond rating. The 5 Town also has a AAA bond rating. 

I could continue but the arithmetic of this letter should be pretty straight forward; an increase in Selectmen from 3 to 5 offers any community the opportunity for more experience, more creativity, more involvement and better representation in town government.   

Attend Town Meeting Sept. 24, 2012.  Vote yes on Warrant Article 4 to increase the Selectmen membership to 5. Enable Sudbury to do better.

Dan DePompei

Haynes Road



Kirsten Vandijk September 11, 2012 at 06:41 PM
I'm curious, Dan. What other town in Massachusetts is lucky enough to have you?
pmotw September 11, 2012 at 08:16 PM
Great letter Mr. DePompei. If you run agian you have our votes.
Scott Nassa September 11, 2012 at 08:33 PM
Great letter Dan! As a friend I hope you run again! This is your best letter yet.
Alison September 12, 2012 at 11:10 AM
Kirsten makes a good point. It would be good to know the name of this town so as informed citizens we can get a feel for how the full time residents think the town is run and whether or not this is a town we want to emulate. ......From what I hear from friends in Wayland, Sudbury is a much better run town with its 3 selectmen than their 5.......And, thank you, Dan, for your plug for the Bruce Freeman Trail.
SueChap September 12, 2012 at 03:09 PM
great letter, Mr. DePompei. thank you for fighting the GOOD fight. The 5 town knows it is lucky to have you as a resident... the 3 town does its best to run empty nesters like you out of town. Support 3 to 5 Selectmen on September 24!


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something
See more »